There is a recurring problem in the history of the #openweb, the people who talk about horizontal organizing often end up reproducing vertical power structures. And because those structures are already recognized by #mainstreaming institutions, the behaviour gets excused, while the native people challenging this mess get marginalized.
The #OMN has been bumping into this problem in its interactions with the #EU and the #NGI funding programmes for years. It’s worth looking back, because there are lessons here that should have informed the development of the paths like the Social Web Foundation.
Five years ago, we were involved in EU-facing discussions about the future of the #openweb. The stated ambition was to support open, decentralized and community-oriented technology. But there was a recurring contradiction between the language of horizontal participation and the actual processes being used. One small example tells the story.
We had a public online #openweb meeting using #BigBlueButton, a tech space for horizontal discussion. Yet the organizers were the only people allowed to contribute to the shared notepad. A moderator had closed access to a feature that was open by default. The result was predictable: public contributions disappeared into the scrolling chat, while the organizers retained control of the permanent record.
This might sound like a small technical detail, it wasn’t, it is a practical expression of the political problem. Who gets to participate? Who controls the record? Who decides what counts as knowledge? Who has the power to shape the outcome?
The #OMN kept pointing out that you cannot build horizontal social technology through vertically controlled processes. And this wasn’t simply criticism, we were offering practical alternatives. The proposal I put forward was straightforward:
- €1 million for outreach: Take existing open technology into real communities of use: schools, activist groups, NGOs, local government and businesses. Let people use it, challenge it and shape its development. Technology without real-world feedback becomes an exercise in developer self-interest, producing endless #techchurn.
- €500,000 for social technology and self-organizing: Build the tools, shared data infrastructure and grassroots governance needed to make the digital commons work.
In other words, balance funding away from exclusively the production of technology to better support for investing in the people, relationships, communities and democratic processes that make technology socially useful.
This was the really obviously missing balance in the #NGI funding culture, yes there was substantial investment in open-source building blocks, but far less recognition that the social infrastructure around those technologies needs investment too. The NGI initiative itself talked about trust, inclusion, decentralization and human-centred technology, the challenge was turning those values into any working everyday practice.
The real value of the #openweb doesn’t originate in EU institutions, technology companies or professional NGO networks. It comes from its grassroots counterculture: protest camps, squats, free parties, activist networks, hacker spaces, independent media and all those messy communities that build outside mainstream power structures.
These communities are not just an outreach audience to be recruited, they are the native social foundations that make the #openweb possible. The current working example is that the #Fediverse is minority-native, it developed through small, often poorly resourced communities, shared interests and grassroots experimentation. That history is a big part of its value, there is a danger when institutional funding arrives with a mainstreaming agenda, you grow the technology while undermining the culture that gave it meaning in the first place.
This is where the Social Web Foundation comes into the story – launched in September 2024, the Social Web Foundation describes its mission as building a growing, healthy, sustainable and multipolar #Fediverse. Its programme includes people, policy, protocols and technical infrastructure. These are worthwhile ambitions.
But the history of the #OMN’s interaction with the EU and #NGI should have been a useful warning to this new vertical institution. You cannot build a multipolar social web simply by making sure there are multiple platforms and technology providers. You also need multiple centres of social power, independent grassroots communities, meaningful participation to grow horizontal governance. Otherwise, you are only reproducing the same vertical structures in a decentralized technical environment.
Its basic stuff they talked about, but put no resources or non vertical focus into – ActivityPub interoperability is not the same thing as ant meaningful path to social democracy. Having the liberal freedom to move between platforms is not the same as having power over the social infrastructure those platforms depend on. And growing the Fediverse is not necessarily the same as strengthening the #openweb.
The recurring missing question is, who gets to shape this growth, and who owns the social processes that sustain it? The #OMN has been working to address precisely these gaps through the #OGB, #indymediaback and our wider #4opens work. To develop the shared processes through which people can publish, subscribe, moderate, organize and govern collectively. This is why I keep coming back to the same points – we need to fund the grassroots, not just the code. We need to support existing communities rather than treating them as recruitment targets. We need to build bridges between institutional funding and counter cultural practice, and then actually secure the resources to maintain those bridges.
The #EU and #NGI had an opportunity to learn this five years ago. The Social Web Foundation has an opportunity to take those lessons seriously now. the problem we need to compost is that nether of them have in anyway actively engendered with this yet. I’m not suggesting that these organizations are identical, or that the #SWF has to adopt the #OMN path. But the #KISS historical lesson is relevant to anyone claiming to build a healthy, sustainable and multipolar social web – don’t mainstream the #openweb out of existence.
Its very basic, please don’t confuse institutional recognition with grassroots legitimacy, technical decentralization with horizontal power, or growth with social progress. Build the bridge, don’t burn the ground you’re standing on. We actually need less #techchurn, more outreach, participation, shared ownership and grassroots governance.
That’s the #openweb reboot we actually need.
