Governance in the Fediverse: Years On, Are We Any Further Beyond Feudalism?

The problem isn’t simply that open source has feudal governance, it’s that by only decentralizing technology we reproduce the same old hierarchy under different names. The#openweb reboot based on the #Fediverse gives us a chance to build something better, but first we need to have the argument that decentralization alone isn’t democracy. Feudalism in code is still feudalism.

Four years ago I was arguing that feudalism was a poor model of governance for #opensource and #freesoftware, that argument hasn’t aged out. Too often, decision-making still rests with project founders, core developers, instance admins, founders and the people who control the infrastructure. Everyone else gets a voice only when those above them choose to listen.

This is the weakness of much of the current path – we have built copy’s of corporate platforms – but carried over their top-down assumptions: gatekeepers, personality politics, informal hierarchies and governance by whoever happens to hold the hard coded roles..

In 2022, we were arguing that decentralizing the technology wasn’t enough, that we also needed to decentralize power, ownership and decision-making. The uncomfortable question in 2026 is have we actually changed the governance, or have we simply reproduced the old power structures on decentralized infrastructure? My reading, that we’ve made some progress in recognizing the problem, but much less progress in building practical alternatives.

Mastodon has recognized the ownership problem. In January 2025 they announced plans to transfer its intellectual property and key assets into a European non-profit structure, explicitly stating that the project should not be owned or controlled by one individual. By November 2025, the transition was still in progress. The proposed Belgian AISBL had not yet taken over, and the existing organizational arrangements are continuing. By February 2026, Mastodon was talking more explicitly about community ownership, governance pathways and involving the wider social-web community in shaping its future.

This is a meaningful change – but there’s an important distinction – moving ownership from an individual to a non-profit organization is not the same as moving power to the community. A board can still be a small group exercising authority over everyone else. The question is who appoints it, who can challenge it, who controls the budget and who has a meaningful say in technical direction.

We have moved the discussion forward, but the democratic question remains. The research has caught up with the problem – there has also been fluffy research into how #Fediverse instances work. The 2024 Governance on Fediverse Microblogging Servers research by Erin Kissane and Darius Kazemi looked at the practical structures used by server teams, they identified problems that grassroots administrators have been experiencing for years:

  • Too much responsibility concentrated in small teams.
  • Weak participation by ordinary users.
  • Inadequate moderation and governance tools.
  • Poor support for cooperative and collective administration.
  • A lack of any shared infrastructure between instances.

There is also newer academic work questioning whether Mastodon’s decentralized architecture actually distributes power as evenly as its public image suggests. That brings grassroots projects closer to the original #OGB argument. That decentralization hasn’t removed the hidden hierarchies, while the Fediverse has continued to grow and diversify, decentralization doesn’t automatically mean democratic control. There are several layers of power:

  • Instance administrators: They control access, moderation, hosting and often the rules of participation.
  • Software maintainers: They decide which features get developed, which contributions are accepted and what technical direction is taken.
  • Funding organisations: They influence which projects receive resources and which approaches become sustainable.
  • Protocol and standards bodies: They influence the underlying rules that determine how the network works.

Even when the code is open, these relationships remain quite closed. Research published in 2025 on defederation also highlighted the difficult balance between local autonomy, collective safety and accountability across independent servers.

We have the move to #NGO and mainstreaming infrastructure that brings the Fediverse more visibility to institutions, governments, NGOs and commercial platforms. That brings opportunities: funding, infrastructure, public attention and wider participation, but it also brings all the dangers of mainstreaming.

We get professionalised organizations, appointed boards, funding priorities and centralized decision-making, all wrapped in the language of community ownership. This co-option of language and power isn’t necessarily intentional, but the structural risk is real.

So looking back what has happened to the #OGB idea? This is where the comparison becomes more personal – the original path is about moving beyond benevolent dictators to creating practical horizontal governance. The idea was to experiment with:

  • Affinity groups rather than permanent hierarchies.
  • Sortition to bring fresh participants into decision-making.
  • Recall so representatives remain accountable.
  • Dilution of concentrated power.
  • Voices and representation for smaller groups.
  • Governance embedded in the software rather than bolted on afterwards.

The important point was never about simply creating another committee or NGO, it was to build governance into the infrastructure itself.

There has been progress in the wider discussion, but the practical development of #OGB, #OMN and #indymediaback, #makeinghistory has remained difficult. The projects have spent much of the past year stuck at the development stage, despite continuing funding applications and some technical work. We have a clearer understanding of the problem, but we haven’t yet built the working alternatives at anywhere near the scale we need. Four years ago, the framing was about moving from feudal open-source structures towards democratic grassroots stakeholder governance.

The realty is nothing has changed, we still need the technology to make these things possible. As if the software only allows administrators to make decisions, then writing a democratic constitution won’t fix the underlying problem. Governance needs to be reflected in the code, data structures, moderation tools and funding arrangements.

So 4 years on we are still at the first step – from feudalism to a working commons. I think the original work was pointing in the right direction, and the last few years have helped clarify the challenge. We don’t just need to replace benevolent dictators with elected committees. What we need is to move away from the assumption that power has to be concentrated somewhere in the first place. This is where the different OMN projects fit together:

  • : The foundation of open data, open process, open standards and open source.
  • #OGB: Practical experiments in horizontal governance, accountability and distributed decision-making.
  • #OMN: The shared data infrastructure connecting people, communities and trusted information flows.

The path of these projects is to build a network of communities that can cooperate without surrendering their autonomy. To make this work we do need to stop treating decentralization as a technical property and start treating it as a social practice. Today, the opportunity is still there, but the problem is clearer. The gap between talking about community governance and actually building it remains the central challenge.

We need to get beyond this – the #openweb needs practical grassroots governance, not another layer of professionalised management. It needs communities with real autonomy, shared infrastructure and the ability to challenge power when it becomes concentrated. That’s the unfinished work of the #OGB and the wider #OMN project.. The #Fediverse is a be a place to try this, but it won’t happen by magic.

Why we need a different path

The problem we face isn’t simply that the system is broken, it’s that we’re still trying to fix it using the thinking that built it. This path of only describing how bad things are, identifying the bad actors and demanding that those in power do better have failed to produce the necessary change. We already know the problems. We have mountains of research, reports, campaigns and expert recommendations. Yet the machinery keeps rolling. Why?

We should understand by now that the problem is deeper than bad decisions or a lack of information, it’s embedded in the social processes through which we create what we accept as rational, reasonable and possible. the work of composting this mess has important connections with what we’ve been trying to work through in the #OMN. The is a trap we need to shovel is the #mainstreaming idea of rationality.

We have inherited a political culture that assumes if we provide enough evidence, make a convincing argument and present a reasonable solution, people and institutions will eventually do the sensible thing. But this isn’t how power works – institutions develop their own interests, habits and survival mechanisms. Media, government, professional organizations and political movements reinforce one another. They create a shared version of reality that becomes detached from the conditions outside of this narrow view.

This is the current problem with #mainstreaming – the constant reproduction of accepted thinking, even when that thinking is clearly failing. The problem isn’t that rational thought has no value, it’s that treating rational argument as the only legitimate way of understanding and changing the world leaves out the emotional, cultural and social processes that actually shape human behaviour. We end up arguing only inside the very framework we need to be challenging.

Over the last 50 years we have made a compleat artificial mess of our society, economics and political systems and this fog of complexity (re)creates the current political paralysis. Responsibility gets distributed across supply chains, institutions, technologies and distant relationships. Harm becomes normalized because nobody sees the whole process or feels directly responsible for its outcomes – createing a dangerous form of desensitization.

We are continually presented with crises, disasters and warnings, each is supposedly unprecedented, yet the next arrives before we’ve processed the last, eventually, even enormous problems become background noise. The #deathcult survives partly through this exhaustion, we become accustomed to systemic failure and lose the ability to imagine anything different.

More information alone won’t fix this, we need different social processes for making sense of complexity and acting collectively. We need circuit breakers, not more common sense hierarchy. One core path to this is projects like the #OGB, with the use of randomly selected body members (voices) to create federated’ assemblies, using three essential elements:

Sortition: bringing people into the process from outside established political and institutional networks.

Free deliberation: giving them space (working groups) to think and work through problems without simply following existing political loyalties.

Real authority: ensuring their conclusions have meaningful social power.

The metaphor that might have power on this needed path is the #circuitbreaker. Instead of allowing the same institutional networks to reproduce the same decisions, introduce a process that interrupts established power and creates space for different outcomes. This for the #OMN is the #OGB: grassroots governance with mechanisms that distribute power, allow participation, enable recall and prevent permanent leadership positions from becoming personal fiefdoms. Its #KISS, we need to build these processes into the technology itself, not bolt them on afterwards.

This possible opening takes us into working alongside the current blinded rationality to try to rebuild human connection. People aren’t rational processing units, social movements aren’t management systems. Trust, shared experience, imagination, solidarity and collective practice are essential parts of how people make change. This is one of the biggest problems with the #geekproblem, the assumption that if we build the correct technical system, the social problems will somehow resolve themselves. They won’t.

Transgression means building outside the existing paths and frameworks, not simply better campaigning, better messaging or more efficient versions of existing institutions. We need to challenge the assumptions that make the current system appear inevitable. For the #OMN, this means moving beyond the familiar cycle of identifying problems, writing reports, applying for funding and waiting for institutional approval. It means rebuilding grassroots media, shared infrastructure, collective governance and human relationships. It means creating practical alternatives that people can participate in.

The #openweb is part of this, not as another technology market, but as a different way of organizing information, ownership and social power.

  • gives us a practical starting point: open data, open source, open standards and open process.
  • #OGB explores how we can build horizontal governance into the foundations rather than relying on whoever happens to hold the keys.
  • #indymediaback is about recovering the grassroots media practices that once made independent networks possible.

These aren’t separate technical projects, they are parts of wider attempts to rebuild the social conditions for collective action. But to make this path work we need to compost the biggest danger, that we fall into the same mess, as the existing system becomes more unstable, we double down on its assumptions. More hierarchy, more professional management, more institutional control, more technology promising to optimize the same broken processes.

This is the familiar #mainstreaming response of absorbing the criticism to turn it into another professional programme and carry on as before. We need to resist that pull, we need to keep to the path as the answer isn’t to find better princes and kings, or to build more sophisticated digital castles. It’s to create systems where power is shared, decisions remain accountable and people can participate without needing permission from above.

We need to compost assumptions, recover the grassroots knowledge buried underneath and grow something different to take the path of less management of the existing mess, more practical experiments in building what comes next. The future won’t arrive as a finished blueprint, we have to grow it together.

A (un)romantic view of composting this with swearing

The liberal fantasy of reforming the #dotcons, ten years on

The working path of reform isn’t simply difficult because the platforms resist it, it’s structurally contradictory. The #dotcons make money by enclosing the social value that reformers want them to release. The liberal mistake is treating this as a problem of corporate behaviour rather than a problem with the underlying economic paths.

We are now ten years on from the mess we solidified with the #dotcons, we have had a decade to watch the platform economy develop and see where the original arguments about reform have led. The question remains unresolved, who owns and governs our shared social data?

This was never simply an argument about advertising, subscription prices or better algorithms, it was about the economic model and social purpose of the infrastructure itself. Ten years on, we need to ask a harder question, was the push to reform the #dotcons ever anything more than a liberal fantasy?

The reform fantasy of 2016 – there was a debate about taking back control of our social media feeds. The proposal was straightforward: loosen API restrictions, allow archiving, searching, filtering and alternative interfaces. Give people control over their attention streams rather than leaving everything to corporate algorithms. It sounded reasonable, but it started from a fundamental misunderstanding.

The #dotcons weren’t built to create a shared social commons. Billions were invested in building commercial silos: capturing users, capturing data and turning our social relationships into advertising inventory. This isn’t an unfortunate side effect of their business model, it IS the business model.

Their value comes from enclosure, their competitive advantage comes from controlling access, their investors expect returns from maintaining that control. So why would we expect these companies to voluntarily dismantle the very systems that make them profitable?

Asking the #dotcons to open their data, loosen their APIs and support independent tools is asking them to undermine their investment model. This isn’t a technical disagreement or a failure of corporate goodwill, it’s a structural contradiction.

The liberal reform argument imagined two possible ways out:

  • Enlightened philanthropy: platform owners voluntarily give up some of their power and release the value they have captured.
  • Public ownership: social infrastructure is taken out of private control and treated as something that should serve the people who created its value.

The first depends on corporate goodwill, the second requires a fundamental change in ownership and power. Neither is a substitute for building alternatives, so with ten years of evidence what have we learned? The #dotcons have become more deeply embedded in everyday social life, their algorithms continue to prioritize engagement and commercial value over public knowledge.

Mainstreaming alternative media has grown up inside these #dotcons platforms, often losing touch with the older #openweb paths, practices and culture they grew from – we have trained a generation of media producers to build their audiences on rented corporate land.

Even the #Fediverse has exposed some of these contradictions, demonstrating that another technical path is possible, but federation alone doesn’t guarantee an open commons. Open protocols still support closed cultures, concentrated power and weak grassroots governance. We have spent years arguing about better platforms while neglecting the social structures needed to make platforms serve collective interests. The problem isn’t simply that the technology is closed, it’s that the ownership, incentives and culture remain organized around enclosure.

What we needed then and what we need now is to stop reforming the enclosure and build the commons. The answer was never simply to make Facebook, Twitter or their successors behave better – we need to stop treating the #dotcons as misunderstood public utilities that only need a little reform – they are commercial infrastructures built to capture social value, their interests and the interests of the people using them are fundamentally different.

Instead of this mess, we need to take the talent, tools and energy currently feeding the #dotcons and put them into rebuilding the #openweb. We need positive ideas of value:

  • #Linking rather than enclosing. Connect information and communities rather than trapping them inside platforms.
  • : open data, open source, open standards and open process.
  • Shared social data rather than corporate-owned social graphs.
  • Independent archiving, searching, filtering and publishing that put people back in control of their information.
  • Grassroots communities with the power to moderate and govern their own spaces.

This is the current grassroots fedivers path and the thinking behind the #OMN – that the mistake of the last ten years has been spending so much energy trying to make the existing silos nicer places to live, rather than building the shared infrastructure that makes them less necessary. The question was never just who controls our feeds, it’s who controls the social value we collectively create. Ten years on, it’s time to stop confusing reforming the #dotcons with rebuilding the #openweb.

Its important to make the distinction explicit: community-based doesn’t mean simply having lots of people in the same network. It means building shared infrastructure, shared responsibility and collective power, rather than treating the network as a collection of individual accounts. One of the blindnesses of the current #openweb crew is the refusal to see the political differences underneath the overlapping technology.

  • The #IndieWeb is strongly individualist: personal sites, personal publishing, personal ownership and individual control. It’s a good fit for capitalism.
  • The #Fediverse has a different potential. It’s more community-based: shared spaces, collective moderation, mutual support, common infrastructure and the ability to organize around shared interests. People aren’t just individual users; they are participants in communities that have some collective responsibility for the spaces they inhabit.

Yet the #Fediverse often presents itself in individualist language to make #mainstreaming outreach easier. A useful white lie, perhaps, but one that hides its deeper possibilities.

They are both native #openweb paths, but they aren’t building the same thing. The #IndieWeb fits comfortably into the existing economic order. The grassroots potential of the #Fediverse offers a way to organize beyond it.

The blindness of today’s crew is wanting to talk about technology while avoiding the politics, culture and power underneath it. Community isn’t an audience or a collection of individual accounts, it’s people building and taking responsibility for something together.

We need to recover that understanding if we’re serious about rebuilding the #openweb. #OMN

Composting the #deathcult means building an alternative

For 40 years we’ve been told there is no alternative. The neoliberal #deathcult has made a religion of markets, competition, individualism and profit. We’ve been told to keep our heads down, accept the consequences and leave everything to the market. Now look at where this has taken us. People work hard but cannot afford housing, food, energy or the basics of a dignified life. Economic insecurity grows while wealth and power concentrate in fewer hands. Democracy becomes hollow when governments tell people that nothing can be done about the things that matter most in their lives.

This is fertile ground for fascism – when the existing system becomes unbearable, we become open to #nastyfew fascists who promise blinded alternatives. On one hand the far right understands this, offering belonging, agency and a mythical better past, but builds that promise around exclusion, hierarchy and the dehumanization of others. On the other hand the progressive failure is that we have not built a convincing alternative.

We cannot simply defend the existing mess and expect people to keep believing in it, nor can we offer abstract utopias without practical paths for getting there. We need to start with the things people actually need:

  • A floor under people’s lives, affordable housing, food, energy, transport and care.
  • A ceiling on concentrated power, challenge monopolies and corporate capture.
  • Shared public infrastructure, public options that put people’s needs before privatized profits.
  • Democracy, participation and collective power in the decisions that shape everyday life.
  • Ecological transition to change how we produce and distribute resources.
  • International solidarity, stop treating the lives and livelihoods of people elsewhere as expendable collateral damage.

But there is another deeper layer we need to take seriously, the social/tech infrastructure that makes these alternatives possible. This is where the #OMN path is useful, we need to rebuild the grassroots networks, independent media, shared spaces and open processes that allow people to organize, communicate, disagree and cooperate. Not more centralized platforms, not more #NGO-shaped projects or another collection of isolated individuals competing for attention.

We need practical commons infrastructure that grows trust, participation and collective agency. The native #openweb is part of this path. Then the give us a practical starting tool: open data, open source, open standards and open processes. this can put more of us on paths were technology supports human relationships and collective organization, not replaces them.

The central lesson is simple – the hard right is offering people a sense of agency in a world that has taken their agency away. We cannot defeat that by simply shouting louder about how bad the far right is, we have to build something people can actually participate in, see working and believe in.

This is social composting – stop defending the rotting system, stop getting trapped in endless symbolic battles. Dig into the shit left by 40 years of #deathcult worship and turn it into the healthy ground for something better. We don’t need another saviour, we need to rebuild the collective ability to act so grab a shovel, build the compost heap, grow the alternative.

Leading in an age of disinformation: who gets to control the truth?

lets look at an example of this. I went to a Kellogg Conversation at Oxford on “Leading in an age of disinformation”. It brought together voices from the BBC, science, policing and business to discuss how leaders should respond when truth is contested and trust is fragile. What was interesting was not just what they said, but what each institution revealed about its own relationship with power.

  • The BBC talked about information control: status games, motivation, fear, help and the growing influence of state actors. Its concern was how established media can retain trust when the old gatekeepers no longer control the flow of information.
  • The police talked about social control. Their interest in social media and influencers was largely about outreach, reaching people through trusted voices and using influence to support policing agendas. There was a strong desire for information to be state sanctioned, controlled and not in any way alternative..
  • Business talked about money control. Influencers, marketing and AI were discussed through the familiar language of reach, reputation and trust. The underlying question was how to make influence work for business.
  • Science was the odd one out. There was more recognition that knowledge is uncertain, that information can be cherry-picked, and that attempts to automate the handling of information can create new problems. There was at least some willingness to question the assumptions behind the systems.

But there was a bigger problem with the whole conversation, nobody was really talking about freedom. Each institution was looking at the #dotcons mess through the lens of the power it already holds. The BBC wants to maintain authority over information. The police want reliable channels for social outreach. Business wants to turn influence into money. Science wants better ways to establish and communicate knowledge. These are not necessarily all bad aims, but they leave out the people and communities who actually create, share and make sense of information.

The problem is that we don’t know as much as these institutions often pretend, the information landscape has changed, but the institutions are still trying to manage it using old habits of authority and control. Influencer culture is a good example. People increasingly use peer-to-peer language and trust relationships to communicate, but that doesn’t make something trustworthy. We need to understand this difference rather than simply trying to recruit influencers into existing systems of control.

One question from the discussion stood out: what are you actually trying to achieve when you tell someone something? That is a much more useful starting point than simply asking whether information is correct. What relationship are you building? What action are you encouraging? Who benefits? Who gets to challenge it?

This is where the #openweb and #OMN paths matter. We need open information flows, visible sources, human context, shared moderation and the ability to challenge and correct what circulates. Not another layer of automated control pretending to solve a social problem. We need to make it easier for people to understand where information comes from, how it travels and why it is being promoted.

The danger is that the old gatekeepers respond to losing control by building new forms of control, while the #dotcons turn the resulting confusion into another market. We need an educational critique of how we are using information, not simply another professional conversation about how to manage it. Trust cannot be manufactured by institutions, bought by business or imposed by the police. It has to grow through open relationships and accountable practice.

Nobody on that panel seemed to be speaking from the starting point of freedom, that absence is the real story.

#OMN #openweb #disinformation #mainstreaming #dotcons

Capitalism is not human nature

One of the most powerful delusions of the #deathcult is our belief that capitalism is human nature, the way we organize work, money, resources and society is how the world works, that there is no alternative. The first step is capitalism is not a natural or spontaneous order, it is a political and economic system that has been built, enforced and maintained through institutions, laws, violence and control. We built it, we can change it.

Capitalism rests on two central relationships: wage labour and private investment, most people have no choice but to sell their ability to work for wages, while a relatively small group controls investment and therefore has enormous influence over what gets produced, why it gets produced and who benefits. The result is production organized around profit rather than human need.

This arrangement did not emerge because people naturally wanted to accumulate wealth, it was built through historical processes of enclosure, dispossession and the removal of people’s ability to sustain themselves outside the market. Once people lose access to land, resources and shared means of survival, they become dependent on selling their labour to survive. This is #KISS not freedom, it is coercion dressed up as (stupid)individual choice.

We are constantly told that austerity is necessary, that public services must be cut, wages restrained and unemployment tolerated to keep the economy functioning. But the unasked question is necessary for whom? Austerity is irrational from the perspective of human need, but, yes, it might be rational within an economic system organized around profit. As keeping people economically insecure weakens their bargaining power and makes them more dependent on wage labour.

The system isn’t necessarily failing when people become poorer while wealth accumulates at the top. It can be doing exactly what it was structured to do. This is why blaming individual greed or a few bad politicians is a manufactured distraction. We need to understand the systemic relationships that reproduce the inequality.

One of capitalism’s most effective blinded ideological tools is the idea that everyone is responsible for their own success or failure. If you are wealthy, you must have worked hard, made good decisions and behaved rationally, if you are poor, you must have made mistakes. This is mainstream #stupidindividualism turned into economic common sense. It hides the relationships of power behind the appearance of individual choice. It encourages people struggling under the system to blame those even worse off, rather than looking at who actually benefits.

This is mess is how the #deathcult maintains its cultural power: not just through coercion, but through consent. People are encouraged to accept the system’s power as their own, even when this power work against their interests.

Capitalism is historically recent, human societies have organized production, resources and relationships in many different ways. There is no single natural economic path that everyone must follow. We should be growing practical alternatives, at the #OMN we are working towards traditions of commons, mutual aid, solidarity economies and participatory democracy. It is practical work in to build and solidify how people come together locally, organize assemblies and begin making collective decisions about resources and paths.

This is important because alternatives cannot simply be written down in academic papers or announced by politicians, they have to be built through practice. People need places where they can learn, organize, experiment and develop the confidence to make decisions together. This is where the #OMN path can become more clear for people.

The #openweb faces a similar problem, we have spent decades allowing the infrastructure of communication and social organization to become dependent on private platforms, commercial investment and corporate control. We are told this is simply how technology works, the #dotcons are inevitable, that centralized platforms are more efficient, and that the only realistic response is to make them slightly nicer.

But this is the same trap, the technology is not neutral, and neither are the economic relationships behind it. Who owns the infrastructure? Who controls the data? Who decides what is visible? Who benefits from the work and relationships that people create? The and the #OMN are practical different paths of shared infrastructure, open data, open standards and open processes, rooted in grassroots participation rather than private enclosure.

We need to move beyond individual self-interest and build the collective capacity to manage the things we depend on. That means community ownership, mutual aid, shared resources, participatory governance and practical alternatives that people can use in everyday life. It also means recognizing that technology alone will not solve social problems. We need the people, relationships and organizing processes that make the technology meaningful.

We need to reclaim the language of freedom, not only the ability to choose between products in a market. This path is about having a real say over the material conditions of our lives: food, housing, work, resources and the systems we depend on. Democracy cannot stop at voting occasionally while economic decisions remain in the hands of elitist monsters. It needs to reach into the everyday organization of society. This is a practical challenge, not just an ideological argument.

We need to start locally, build alternatives that meet real needs, connect those experiments and create pressure for wider change. The #OMN is part of this work, not a grand solution delivered from above, but an path to build the shared media, information and governance infrastructure that helps grassroots communities develop collective agency.

We are not trapped because capitalism is human nature. We are trapped because we have allowed a particular set of social relationships to become normal, invisible and difficult to challenge. The first step is to see the trap, the next is to build outside it. We built this world, we can build something different. A path of more #lifecult, less #deathcult. More commons, less enclosure. More collective agency, less #stupidindividualism.

The current centrist revolt won’t change the system that produced Trump and the rest of our hard right mess. It might remove one president and replace him with another, but it won’t dismantle the economic power, imperial interests, class structures and political culture that keep producing these outcomes. Trump isn’t the system’s opposite or some unfortunate accident, he’s a product of it.

Too much focus and energy is wasted on #mainstreaming story’s, as though defeating a #nastyfew man will somehow resolve the deeper crisis. This is a convenient, but nasty, distraction: it turns a structural struggle into a personality contest leaving the machinery of power invisible to carry on untouched. The problem isn’t just who occupies the White House or any other centre of vertical power. It’s the entire system, the culture that normalizes it, and the empire that sustains it. We need system-level thinking at the forefront of political dialogue, not another round of #fashionista personality politics and electoral theatre.

But #dotcons social media algorithms reward exactly the opposite: simple enemies, endless outrage, tribal loyalty and shit agents. They push the symptoms into the spotlight while hiding the structures that produce them. And we shouldn’t blame the algorithms alone. They exploit a political culture already addicted to spectacle, easy answers and the fantasy that changing the face at the top will change the world underneath.

The challenge is to stop confusing a change of political management with a change of system. We don’t need a different caretaker for the same failing order. We need to build the collective power to change the order itself #KISS

The work of composting the #deathcult and growing something more human

The world is such a mess, partly this is because we use fear as a motivation to grasp for control were we should be reach for competence instead. The mess this makes needs shovels to work at composting, it is what tools like the #OMN are trying to provide, but to close this circle we have to first make them, then pick them up, then use them to shovel the #techshit into compost that is in part feeding this mess.

So what is blocking this work? In part it is we use language irresponsibly, and partly that this is a class issue. Groups feed back and reinforce bad language, forming tribes, these blinded groups then ingest the sickness and poison from each other. This is the world we have created over the last 50 years, shaped by the “law of the jungle”, where people behave less like humans and more like animals.

The irony is that the people with the most agency are often the most afraid of change. This is particularly visible in the #fashionista crew, Who constantly block necessary change, making process nasty and often violent until crisis overwhelms their fear. Only then do some maybe finally use their agency to try to save the situation, late and messily, when much of the damage is to late to be avoided

Lets look at this wider, there is a bigger argument than the current chattering class noise – how the last 50 years of #neoliberal culture reshaped social behaviour, language and, most importantly, our ability to act collectively. This connects to the #geekproblem, #fluffy/#spiky divide, #NGO #mainstreaming and why rebuilding the #openweb requires changing social norms, not only writing better #FOSS software.

Over the last 50 years, #neoliberalism shaped the social environment we live in, competition, individual advancement, insecurity and the worship of markets become normalized. We have been encouraged to see ourselves as competing individuals rather than participants in shared social paths. This is not simply a communication problem, it is a class problem, a cultural problem and ultimately a problem of collective growing any agency paths. Words that should help us understand the world have become tribal signals, instead of describing reality, they mostly describe which group we belong to, who we trust and who we are supposed to oppose.

The resulting mess where groups feed back their own language, assumptions and prejudices to each other is a feedback loop few try and escape from. They form tribes that develop internal vocabularies that reinforce their versions of reality. These closed feedback loops become increasingly disconnected from any idea of the wider world. People ingest the same social sickness and then pass it around, often believing they are defending something good, this is how bad ideas become new social norms.

Language should be a tool for exploring reality, negotiating differences and developing shared understanding, instead, much of our political and technological culture uses language as a form of social sorting. Words like safe, inclusive, progressive, radical, professional, disruptive, community and innovation lose their descriptive meaning and become membership badges.

The important thing for #mainstreaming is using the approved language rather than understanding the underlying reality, a strange situation were people become skilled at talking about social change while becoming increasingly unable to participate in it. We see this across our #openweb reboot were projects spend more time managing the language around participation than actually developing meaningful participation. The #fluffy approach then blindly turns kindness into avoidance – the #spiky approach can turn honesty into aggression. Both can become self-protecting tribes rather than useful approaches to collective work.

The class problem behind the tribes is that these behaviours don’t develop in a vacuum. Different social groups experience the world differently, have different resources and face different risks. They also develop different forms of agency, some people have professional security, institutional connections and the ability to move between funded projects. Others have practical skills, lived experience and grassroots relationships but little institutional recognition or financial security. These differences shape how people behave, for example:

  • The professional #NGO layer: Often has access to funding, institutional language and organizational influence. Its poison can be turning political struggle into manageable projects, consultation and career development. Its value is organizational experience, resources and the ability to maintain long-term work.
  • The #fashionista layer: Gains influence through cultural positioning, language and social legitimacy. Its poison can be conformity, status competition and policing who belongs. Its value is cultural energy, communication and the ability to bring new people into movements.
  • The technical #geekproblem layer: Gains agency through specialist knowledge, software and infrastructure. Its poison can be control, abstraction and the assumption that technical functionality solves social problems. Its value is practical skills, maintenance and the ability to build working tools.
  • The grassroots #spiky layer: Often has direct experience of organizing, conflict and practical resistance. Its poison can be hostility, burnout and destructive internal conflict. Its value is independence, political clarity and willingness to challenge established power.
  • The grassroots #fluffy layer: Often brings care, mediation, inclusion and relationship-building. Its poison can be conflict avoidance, endless consensus-seeking and enabling existing power. Its value is trust, participation and the social glue that keeps communities together.

These are all tendencies, not fixed identities. People move between them, and most projects contain several of these cultures at once, the thing is to understand that every group brings something useful and every group can also bring something destructive, we need to understand both. #Fluffy and #spiky: Two necessary sides of collective agency – the #fluffy/#spiky divide is a useful way of understanding a recurring problem in grassroots organizing.

#Fluffy

  • Trust and relationships
  • Care and inclusion
  • Mediation and consensus
  • Social stability

Failure mode: avoiding necessary conflict.

#Spiky

  • Challenge and resistance
  • Political clarity
  • Boundaries and accountability
  • Willingness to act

Failure mode: turning every disagreement into a battle.

Neither is enough on its own – without #fluffy, movements become hostile, exhausting and difficult to sustain. Without #spiky, movements become places where difficult questions are endlessly postponed and existing power is protected. To start to compost this mess we need to repair our grassroots groups so they can change the social norms to make these approaches work better together agen. Kindness must not mean avoiding accountability. Honesty must not mean abandoning care. A healthy movement needs both the ability to welcome people and the ability to challenge them.

The law of the jungle and the loss of human behaviour is another uncomfortable part of this argument. After 50 years of competitive individualism, much of our social behaviour is the law of the jungle. People become defensive, territorial, status-conscious and opportunistic. They protect their immediate position, compete for scarce resources and treat other people as threats or opportunities. This isn’t because people have somehow become less human by nature, it is because the systems we have built reward these behaviours. When insecurity becomes normal, trust becomes risky, when competition becomes normal, cooperation needs justification, when status becomes the measure of success, collective achievement becomes difficult to recognise.

We end up with groups that can talk endlessly about solidarity while behaving according to the opposite logic, this is one of the worst contradictions of the current #deathcult worship. We built social systems that undermine the very human qualities we need to change these systems.

The agency paradox: Those most able to act can become the biggest blockers is a particularly important contradiction. Some of the people with the greatest social agency are also the people most afraid of change. They have established positions, reputations, networks, professional identities and cultural influence, have learned how to operate within the existing system. They may have the resources to initiate change, but they also have the most to lose if the ground shifts beneath them, this is where the #fashernista problem becomes particularly visible.

The people who are most confident in progressive language tend to be the least willing to support actual structural change. They to often block emerging processes, challenge uncomfortable ideas, demand endless consultation and make practical experimentation socially difficult. They don’t necessarily do this consciously, as often they believe they are protecting the community, maintaining standards and preventing harm, but the outcome is the same: pre-emptive obstruction.

Then something interesting happens, as a crisis develops, the old structures begin to fail. Eventually the consequences become impossible to ignore. Suddenly, some of the same people who resisted change discover their agency. They start organizing, making decisions and taking responsibility, but by then the situation is much worse, the opportunity for gradual, thoughtful change has been lost. What could have been a manageable transition becomes a nasty and destructive crisis, the people who could have helped prevent the crisis discover their agency only when the crisis starts to threaten them directly. This is a currently a recurring failure of mainstreamed progressive culture: fear of manageable change produces the conditions for unmanageable change.

Functionality – People have different ideas about what works – this explains why arguments about functionality are often so difficult. People don’t approach a project with neutral ideas about what works, they bring their social position, experience, expectations and cultural assumptions. For one group, functionality means safety, predictability and professional standards, for another, it means speed, experimentation and getting something working. For another, it means participation, inclusion and making sure nobody is excluded, for another, it means political effectiveness and the ability to challenge established power.

These are not simply different opinions about people, software or project management, they are different ideas about how society should work. The problem comes when one group assumes its own definition of functionality is universal – this is particularly visible in the #geekproblem – the assumption that if something works technically, it must work socially, it doesn’t. A technically “perfect” platform can support terrible social relationships, a beautifully inclusive process can produce nothing useful, a politically radical project can destroy its own community through internal conflict.

We need to judge functionality across the whole system:

  • Does it work technically?
  • Does it work socially?
  • Does it support meaningful participation?
  • Does it distribute agency?
  • Can people challenge and change it?
  • Can it survive conflict, failure and changing circumstances?

This is why we need to bring in native development. As changing the social norms is needed, we cannot solve these problems simply by asking people to be nicer, more inclusive or more radical. Those often become just more tribal signals, we need different social practices. Some starting points:

  • Make disagreement normal. Conflict is not automatically a failure. The ability to disagree openly without destroying relationships is a foundation of collective work.
  • Separate criticism of ideas from attacks on people. We need to be able to say that a process is broken without turning every argument into a personality conflict.
  • Reward practical agency. Value the people who maintain, build, organise, experiment and take responsibility, not just those who are best at managing the language around projects.
  • Make power visible. Who decides? Who controls resources? Who can block progress? Who benefits from the existing arrangements?
  • Allow experimentation. Small failures are often cheaper than large, delayed failures. We need room to try different approaches without demanding institutional approval for everything.
  • Build accountability into care. Being welcoming does not mean accepting destructive behaviour. Being challenging does not mean abandoning collective responsibility.
  • Protect the commons. The people who contribute to a shared resource must have meaningful ways to influence and govern it.

The #OMN path is about this – building social technology for human agency, it is why the #OMN is not simply a software project – balanceing – growing social technology that supports different groups, different cultures and different forms of agency without allowing one group to capture the whole path or process. But as people likely reply, openness alone isn’t enough, we also do need the social practices that make openness useful.

The #OMN approach is to build networks of flows rather than centralized platforms. People and communities publish, subscribe, moderate, curate and maintain relationships with information. Trust develops through human participation rather than being imposed by a single algorithm or management structure. The #OGB work is about building the governance needed to make that shared infrastructure accountable. And #indymediaback is about recovering the grassroots publishing and organizing practices that made the native #openweb meaningful in the first place.

These projects need to work across the different social cultures, not become or be seen as another tribe defending its own assumptions. We need #fluffy people who can build trust, #spiky people who can challenge power, technical people who can maintain infrastructure and organizers who can turn shared intentions into practical action. None should dominate, all should be accountable.

The bigger change is that the last 50 years have normalized a particular kind of anti social behaviour: competitive, defensive, individualistic and increasingly disconnected from collective responsibility. To step away from this mess, we need to stop pretending that better interfaces, nicer language or another round of professional management will fix this. The problem is deeper, we need to rebuild the social norms that make collective agency possible. That means learning to recognize the different poisons circulating through our groups, understanding the useful capacities hidden inside those same groups, and finding ways to bring those capacities into productive relationships.

We need to stop rewarding people for defending their positions and start rewarding people for helping communities move forward, and most importantly, we need to stop waiting for crisis to give people permission to act. The point of grassroots organizing is to build the agency to change things before the crisis arrives, the work is of composting the #deathcult and growing something more human.

Breaking the openweb won’t stop the bad bots

It’s interesting that #mainstreaming tech makes it easy to use you, while alternative tech makes it hard to use freedom. One is built for control – and works very well at it. The other is built for freedom – but often works badly at delivering it. That’s the real #techshit problem we face, we need to make freedom easier to use than control.

The latest #fashionista panic about AI scraping is exposing a real problem with how we understand and defend the #openweb. Faced with aggressive commercial data extraction by the #dotcons and #AI industry, the response from parts of the traditional media establishment and mainstreaming policymakers is to restrict automated access, demand identification and introduce new controls over who can collect available information. This is the wrong direction.

We have a genuine problem of #dotcons extracting open flows, enormous amounts of public information, imposing costs on the people who create, host and maintain it. They take the value generated by the #openweb, feed it into proprietary systems and then build closed commercial products that bypass the original sources. This is another round of enclosure.

But shutting down the tools that make the #openweb work is not a solution, it leads to destroying the infrastructure we need to challenge this enclosure. The native #openweb depends on open flows, automated crawling, scraping, indexing, archiving and redistribution are not some new abuse of the internet. They are fundamental parts of how the native #openweb develops.

Search engines, independent journalism, public-interest research, accessibility projects, security monitoring and archives all depend on the ability to collect and process publicly available information. The Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine has preserved more than a trillion web pages. Investigative journalists have used automated collection to expose conflicts of interest in government. Researchers use it to examine discrimination, misinformation and corporate behaviour.

These activities need the #KISS ability to follow information across the web without asking permission from every website owner. Sometimes anonymity is needed, if a journalist, researcher or activist investigating powerful interests has to identify themselves and explain what they are looking for, the investigation itself is compromised. An #openweb cannot depend on asking permission from every gatekeeper before we see, collect, preserve and share public information.

The problem is extraction, not openness – we need to distinguish between two very different things. There is grassroots, public-interest use of automated tools to make information accessible, preserve knowledge and connect communities. Then there is the #dotcons industrial-scale commercial extraction, the gray area were they take the collective output of the openweb, concentrate it into private databases and use it to build proprietary #closedweb services. These are not the same activity.

The problem is not that information flows freely, it is that the value created by those flows is being enclosed and privately captured. Making every crawler identify itself doesn’t solve this. A commercial scraper can identify itself and still overwhelm a server with requests. Meanwhile, an independent archivist or journalist could be deterred from doing legitimate work simply because they cannot safely disclose their identity. We need to regulate harmful behaviour, not criminalize the basic mechanisms of openness.

The #geekproblem is about trying to control the mess instead of fixing it. When faced with complex social and technical problem, the instinct is to introduce another layer of technical control, identification and permission. But the native #openweb was built on a different understanding: distributed participation, open protocols, independent servers and the ability to connect information across organizational boundaries.

We should be strengthening the infrastructure that allows independent websites, archives and communities to survive. What the #OMN adds is rebuilding the commons. The answer is not to retreat into closed platforms, private APIs, permission-based networks or another generation of corporate-controlled infrastructure. We need to rebuild the shared flows, it is not about pretending that every use of public information is harmless. It is about building the social and technical capacity to distinguish useful participation from destructive extraction.

Don’t repeat the mistake – for too long, we have allowed the #dotcons to take the value of the native #openweb while selling us increasingly closed replacements. Now, faced with the consequences, some people want to restrict the openness that made the internet useful in the first place. We cannot allow the response to commercial enclosure to become another round of enclosure. The native #openweb was never perfect, it has technical debt, weak governance, funding problems and social conflicts. But it gave us something we have largely lost, the possibility of building collective power through open information flows. We need to recover that.

The answer to bad bots is not to break the web, the answer to commercial extraction is not to close public information, the answer to platform power is not another platform with more controls. The path is simple, we need to reboot the #openweb, not shut it down. That means rebuilding the grassroots communities, shared infrastructure and collective governance that allow openness to grow real social value.

https://www.techpolicy.press/breaking-the-open-web-wont-stop-the-bad-bots

Oxford, academia and the problem of #mainstreaming

One thing I keep noticing around Oxford is how much academic culture is about building consensus on how to name things, rather than actually talking about the things themselves. Events become status games: establishing who has authority, who gets referenced, who belongs in the #mainstreaming hierarchy around whatever subject is being discussed. There is plenty of time spent establishing credibility, positioning and agreeing on language, but remarkably little time spent getting to grips with the actual mess we increasing face.

Of course, referencing and academic rigour have their uses. We cannot all discover everything from scratch, and taking some things on good authority is necessary. But there is a balance, at some point we need to get beyond repeating what other people have said and ask, what is your contribution? What are you actually doing with this knowledge?

This isn’t an attack on academia or academics, it’s about recognizing the limits of a culture that can become more concerned with its own status and legitimacy than with the subject it claims to be studying. Well, perhaps spending less time establishing who is allowed to talk about the problem and more time actually talking about it would be a good start. Oxford has no shortage of clever people. What we seem to lack is a culture that turns all that knowledge into collective agency and practical change. We don’t need more consensus about how to describe the mess. We need to start doing something about it.

#OMN angle is that economics became another form of chattering-class authority: a closed conversation where mathematical models and professional status gained more weight than lived experience, social relationships and the actual workings of human communities.

Modern economics has a strange problem. It has spent more than a century building an elaborate mathematical model of human behaviour, then started treating that model as if it were human nature itself. The people inside this model are called Homo economicus: perfectly rational, endlessly informed individuals who act only in their own self-interest. They have the memory of a supercomputer, the reasoning power of Einstein and the self-control of Gandhi. The problem? These people don’t exist.

Real human beings are social, emotional, cooperative, competitive, contradictory and shaped by the communities around them. We live through relationships, shared expectations, social norms and collective action. Evolution has spent millions of years shaping these behaviours. But the mainstreaming economic establishment pushed this messy reality aside because it was harder to fit into mathematics.

This is where the #chatteringclasses come in, an educated professional class builds its authority through specialist language, prestigious institutions, awards and internal agreement. The models become more important than the world they are supposed to describe. Dissent is tolerated at the edges, but the central assumptions remain protected.

Even Nobel-winning economists demonstrate that real people behave differently, the great theoretical machine carries on. What should be evidence that the model is wrong gets labelled a paradox that needs explaining away. The irony is that early economists like Adam Smith had a much richer understanding of human nature. Smith recognized that people care about reputation, fairness, social expectations and other people, not just their own monetary advantage. His invisible hand was about how social systems emerge from local interactions, not a magical proof that selfishness makes everything work.

This matters beyond economics, as it is a familiar pattern across our institutions: a professional class creates a simplified model, builds careers and authority around it, then treats the model as reality. When the real world refuses to behave, the response is to defend the model rather than learn from experience. We see the same #geekproblem in technology, the same #NGO problem in activism and the same #mainstreaming problem across pushing back grassroots movements. Process becomes paperwork, participation becomes consultation, and mathematical or professional legitimacy replaces any collective understanding.

For the #OMN, this is a central lesson. Human systems cannot be built from abstract models of isolated individuals. They grow through relationships, trust, shared practice, conflict, cooperation and the messy work of communities. We need to stop confusing the map with the territory, and stop giving the chattering classes a monopoly on describing the world. Less worship of abstract models, more attention to how people actually live, organize and work together.

That’s part of rebuilding the #openweb, not just better technology, but better ways of understanding and organizing our shared social reality.

The rot of Couchsurfing is mainstreaming decay in #openweb paths

From hospitality exchange to venture capital, from grassroots community to corporate platform. The story of #Couchsurfing is a warning about what happens when we confuse building a network with building a community. The story of Couchsurfing is more interesting than a failed social network, it is a history of what happened to native #openweb paths when grassroots roots are overtaken by #NGO turns, startup culture and eventually the fantasies of the #dotcons.

There are lessons here for anyone trying to rebuild an open, grassroots internet today.. The roots were always social, not technological. Hospitality exchange didn’t begin with the internet, networks like Servas, founded in 1949, built on a simple human idea: people open their homes, share resources and create relationships across cultural and national boundaries. Later came Esperanto networks, Hospitality Club, Couchsurfing and more. The internet didn’t invent this, but it gave an existing movement new tools to organize, communicate and grow. This is a native lesson, the technology grows from existing human relationships and grassroots practice, not pretending we create community from nothing.

Hospitality Club, founded in 2000, was built through voluntary programming, translation, moderation, member support and organizing. Couchsurfing (#CS) grew from volunteers organizing local groups, hosting travellers, running potlucks, to built relationships and created a culture that no software company could have manufacture. The website was a small part of the infrastructure, the network was people.

The first failure on this path, was confusing community goodwill with ownership. Couchsurfing’s 2006 database crisis showed the strength of original model. Volunteers helped raise money and rebuilt the platform in ten days, think about that. A community mobilize people, money and technical skills to rescue shared infrastructure because people believed in what they were building.

But this created a fundamental question that the native #openweb has repeatedly failed to answer, who owns the value created by community? The volunteers had supplied labour, expertise, relationships and trust, yet they had no reliable guarantee that the resulting infrastructure would remain under community control. Disputes over volunteer code, NDAs and management transparency exposed this.

BeVolunteer and BeWelcome emerged from this wider conflict, attempting to build the same community based on more formal nonprofit organization and participation. This was an #NGO fork in the road, one path treated community participation as the foundation of a shared resource, the other treated it as an asset that could be managed, controlled and eventually sold.

The #CS NGO turn was replacing grassroots power with professional management, this is where the story connects to the wider #openweb, as grassroots networks grew, they increasingly encounter the world of professional nonprofits, foundations, institutional funding and eventually venture capital. The promise was sustainability, reality was a transfer of power.

Instead of building stronger grassroots governance, projects began importing management structures from the institutions they were supposed to offer alternatives to. Consultants, boards, executives, funding applications, professional communications and organizational hierarchies. The people who actually made the networks were pushed towards the edges. #CS move towards private commercial ownership in 2011 was a example of this mess.

A reported $7.6 million investment round, followed by further venture funding, transformed a community-oriented network into a privately controlled company. Members were not meaningfully consulted about the transfer, the wiki disappeared, community information became private, volunteer structures changed and growth became a corporate priority. The language of community remained, the community’s power did not.

This is the #NGO problem, hollowing out grassroots relationships that brings the value. Not every nonprofit follows this path, #BeWelcome and other alternatives demonstrate that different organizational choices are possible. The problem is not paying people or raising money, the problem is allowing the funding structure to displace the community’s purpose and control.

Couchsurfing eventually became a example of the #dotcons business fantasy of growth, not community. The assumption was that the vertical scaling of more members, more investment, more marketing and more professional management would produce a stronger network. And yes for a time, the network might grow while its social purpose disappeared.

This is the contradiction of the #dotcons, they measure growth in accounts, engagement, traffic and financial value, while the thing that has value, the human network comes from trust, participation, reciprocity and relationships. You can buy growth, you cannot buy the social fabric that makes a network work in meaningfully ways.

In 2020, Couchsurfing introduced mandatory contributions in many countries, making access conditional on payment. People who had spent years building the network were now being forced to pay to access the relationships and infrastructure they had create. The problem behind this was a normal mainstreaming one, it wasn’t only that the network needed money, the problem was who controlled it, who decided how it was funded and who benefited from the value it generated.

This fall is when the community starts to leave, the platform is already dead, the failure of Couchsurfing wasn’t a particular CEO, funding round or paywall, it was the gradual destruction of the reciprocal relationship between the platform and its community. This is an important distinction for the #openweb, a network can remain technically online long after its community has disappeared.

A project can have excellent open-source software while having no meaningful grassroots movement around it. The native #openweb was never just about publishing code, it was about building shared infrastructure through shared practice. When you remove that practice, you are left with an increasingly hollow technical shell.

What we can learn from this dead native #openweb project? This might be useful for current projects like the #fedivers, there are some of the lessons:

  1. Build the community before scaling the technology. Start with existing relationships, local groups, shared practices and real needs. Software should strengthen these relationships, not replace them.
  2. Make governance part of the infrastructure. Don’t leave governance until after the software is built. Open code without open processes still produce closed power structures. Participation, transparency, accountability and the ability to challenge decisions need to be designed into the project from the beginning.
  3. Don’t confuse funding with sustainability. Money is necessary for developers, hosting, administration and maintenance. But funding should support the community rather than turn the community into a resource for funders.
  4. Build networks, not platforms. A platform concentrates control, a network of interoperable, independently maintained communities distributes it. Shared data, open standards, portable identities and federated infrastructure make it harder for one organization to capture the network.
  5. Value participation, not just numbers. A few hundred active people who trust each other, maintain the infrastructure and take collective responsibility can be worth more than millions of inactive accounts.

This is why we need the #OMN, history is relevant to what we are trying to build, the #OMN, #OGB and #indymediaback. The native #openweb had the right instincts: open standards, voluntary participation, shared resources, grassroots organization and trust between people. But it repeatedly failed to build durable structures to protect those values when projects grew, funding arrived and professional management took over.

We need to learn from that history rather than keep repeating it. The #OMN starts from a different place, not another social media platform competing for accounts and attention, it is a path to grow a shared network of media flows, where communities can publish, subscribe, moderate, curate and maintain their own connections to information. The technical foundation is important, but it is only one part of the work.

  • : Open data, open source, open standards and open process.
  • #OGB: Grassroots governance that makes collective ownership and accountability practical.
  • #indymediaback: Rebuilding community-based publishing and local media.
  • #MakingHistory: Building shared, federated archives where communities participate in preserving and interpreting their histories.

The working path is to make the social relationships, data and infrastructure reinforce each other rather than allowing one organization to capture the value of the whole network. This is also why we need to resist the #NGO turn and the #dotcons fantasy. Both encourage us to hand over grassroots power in exchange for promises of professional delivery, scale and sustainability. #Couchsurfing shows where that road can lead, we shouldn’t build big networks, rather we need to build the grassroots foundations that allow networks to grow without losing their purpose.

And that’s what we mean by the #OMN.

The #OMN path is about the stories we tell to make technology acceptable

The #OMN path is about the stories we tell to make technology acceptable, the institutions that repeat those stories, and the grassroots work left waiting while the money follows the next “miracle” story. A useful tool gets wrapped in a grand narrative, funding follows the narrative rather than community need, and the people building alternatives are pushed to the margins. When the story finally weakens, the underlying technology may remain – but the promised social transformation never arrives.

The story is always bigger than the technology, and when the story collapses, the people trying to build something useful are left to compost the mess. The AI hype is beginning to meet this reality that caught up with so many previous waves of technology. The promises were enormous: artificial general intelligence, automated abundance, the end of work as we know it, and machines that would solve the problems we have failed to solve ourselves. Trillions in investment followed the story.

But beneath the #PR claims the practical uses remain much more ordinary. Large language models (#LLM) do have useful capabilities. But they are not evidence that we have created a new form of human intelligence, nor do they justify meany of the promises made in their name. The interesting question is not whether the technology has some value, it clearly does. The question is why we keep wrapping useful tools in stories of technological salvation, and why so much of our social and political life gets pulled into those stories.

Every technology comes with a story, we have seen this cycle meany times. The #dotcons, social media promised to connect the world. #Web3 promised to decentralize it. #Blockchain promised to rebuild trust. Now #AI promises to automate intelligence itself. Each wave arrives with a familiar script, first, a genuine technical development, then a much bigger story about what it means for humanity. Blinded investors pour in money, bureaucratic businesses scramble to adopt it, governments fear being left behind, and the traditional media repeats the promise until it starts to feel like transentery common sense.

The technology becomes almost impossible to discuss outside its mythology, is how the #deathcult works, it turns a economic and political path into an inevitable dead end future. We are told to adapt, adopt and accelerate, because questioning the direction means falling behind. But as always, the question of who benefits disappears beneath the pressure to keep up. To compost this mess we need to separate what the technology can actually do from the stories being sold around it, as if we accept the industry’s framing that today’s language models are becoming digital people, even our criticism ends up strengthening that framing. The task is to compost the mythology, the failed dreams of #mainstreaming.

But we face is what happens when the story’s collapse, who pays? The AI industry sold different stories to different audiences. Consumers were promised an intelligent assistant. Businesses were promised efficiency and reduced labour costs. Governments were warned that they must join a geopolitical race. Workers were told they were participating in a historic mission. Investors were promised extraordinary returns. These stories reinforced one another. Government investment legitimized the industry. Corporate adoption made it appear inevitable. Financial speculation funded further expansion. Media attention turned uncertainty into spectacle.

And when this investment bubble deflates, the damage will not be limited to shareholders. Public resources have been committed to speculative infrastructure. Workers have lost jobs in anticipation of automation that never delivered as promised. Communities may be left with more centralized infrastructure and less control over the information systems they depend on. Yes, the technology will continue in some form, the question is more who ends up owning it, who benefits from it and who is left holding the bill.

There are are likely useful things we can do with language models. They can help people process information, translate material, assist with coding and make some technical tasks more accessible. We should assess those uses honestly, including their limitations and costs. But we do not need to pretend these tools will create a new civilization, we do not need to build our communities around corporate #dotcons products, by handing over public knowledge to private platforms to replace human judgement with automated output.

We do need to ask what tools can contribute to collective work, and what relationships must remain human, accountable and open to challenge. For #OMN, this means keeping our focus on shared media flows, grassroots publishing, archives and the commons. The work is to help communities create, discover, moderate and maintain their own information systems. On this path the offer a practical test: open data, open source, open standards and open processes. These do not magically guarantee a good outcome, but they make it easier to inspect, reuse, challenge and improve the systems we build.

The #AI story needs compost, not another hype cycle. There is a useful ecological metaphor here, composting does not mean pretending that everything discarded is worthless. It means separating what can nourish future growth from what needs to break down. The AI boom contains technical developments, useful tools, accumulated knowledge and some worthwhile experiments. It also contains inflated promises, speculative finance, extractive business models and a great deal of #techchurn.

That means, focus, shifting our attention away from chasing the next big story and towards the less glamorous work of building things people actually use. Shared infrastructure. Open processes. Community maintenance. Human trust. The ability to disagree, adapt and walk away. This work will not attract the same speculative billions. It may never produce a spectacular demonstration or a promise of god-like intelligence. Good.

We need less technological theatre and more collective capability, less dependency and more participation, less worship of the #deathcult and more practice of the #lifecult. The AI bubble will deflate, or the industry may keep finding new ways to keep the story alive. Either way, the underlying choice remains, do we build alternatives or keep chasing the next #mainstreaming day dream, or maybe better, do we practically use the wreckage of these failed promises to grow something more useful?

The #OMN path is to compost the hype, keep the useful tools, expose the power relationships and build the commons. Not one perfect platform, not one miracle technology, a living ecosystem of tools, communities and shared practices that grow beyond the control of the #dotcons.

There is no magic, there is only work.

#AI mythology is currently more of the same
The #openweb is #4opens, where dues this place the current #AI path?

The #openweb is a network of links, not islands

Ten years ago, I wrote about a problem that was already undermining the #openweb, that nobody was linking to anybody, and that the incentives were all moving in the wrong direction. #Mainstreaming platforms had little reason to send people towards alternative sources, while grassroots projects were left struggling to build connections with each other. Even when people wanted to cooperate, there were plenty of reasons to avoid linking, sharing audiences or giving another project visibility.

The result was an increasingly fragmented web. Lots of websites, lots of content, lots of people doing useful work, but fewer if any meaningful connections between them. Ten years later, the technology has changed, the underlying problem has not gone away. In some ways, it has become worse, as the attention economy has eaten the #openweb. The commercial internet is built around capturing attention, the more time people spend inside a platform, the more valuable that audience becomes to its owners. External links interrupt this process, they send people somewhere else, towards another publisher, another community or another source of information.

From the perspective of the #dotcons, this is a problem to manage, as their business model rewards keeping people inside their own environments, controlling discovery and turning the activity of users into something that can be measured, monetized and sold. Likewise search engines increasingly provide answers directly, social platforms prioritize their own feeds and recommendation systems and publishers compete for visibility inside systems they do not control.

The #openweb still has hyperlinks, but the “common sense” culture surrounding them has changed. The problem is not that links have disappeared, it is that the common sense dominating online life have weak incentives to support an open, reciprocal network of independent publishers. This matters because the web was never supposed to be a collection of isolated destinations. Its strength came from the connections between them: people following sources, discovering unexpected ideas, checking evidence, finding communities and building on each other’s work. Take those connections away, and the web becomes a collection of competing islands.

We have been building better technology, but federation is not enough, over this last ten years, the #Fediverse has grown, ActivityPub has become more visible, and more websites connect with decentralized social networks. This is real progress, we now have more technical possibilities for building an alternative to the centralized paths. But there is #blocking, we to often grow federated social networks that still reproduce the habits of closed #dotcons social media.

Federation connects systems, it does not create solidarity these systems need to work. The same applies to #FOSS, open-source software. Open code is important, but it does not guarantee that projects will cooperate, share audiences or build lasting relationships. Technical openness is necessary, but it is not sufficient. This is where the become useful: open code, open data, open standards and open processes. They can be used to give us a practical foundation for cooperation, but we still have to build the culture that makes that cooperation meaningful.

The mainstreaming trap… ten years ago, I described the difficulty of getting #mainstreaming alternatives to link to each other. This underlying tension remains, grassroots projects need reach, resources and recognition, mainstream organizations have their own priorities, reputation concerns and institutional incentives. They will link externally when it serves their purposes, the problem is that those links are selective and instrumental rather than part of a wider commitment to an open information commons.

Grassroots projects end up supplying stories, ideas, research and community knowledge to organizations that gain the attention while the original producers receive little in return. This is one of the quieter forms of #mainstreaming. The grassroots become useful contributors to somebody else ‘s system without building the independent relationships needed to sustain their own. The answer to this smell is not to refuse every mainstream connection, that would be another kind of isolation. It is a balancing act, work with wider institutions when useful, but maintain independent infrastructure, reciprocal relationships and the ability to carry on without their permission. We need bridges, not gateways that leave us dependent on whoever controls the other end.

Why don’t the grassroots simply link to each other? This is where the problem becomes more uncomfortable, as it is easy to blame the #dotcons as their incentives are obvious. It is harder to look at the habits and assumptions within our own communities. Grassroots projects compete for the same funding, audiences, volunteers and recognition. People worry about sending attention elsewhere. Organizations protect their own identities, developers build separate platforms, campaigns create separate communication channels.

Sometimes this mess happens for understandable reasons. Projects have limited time and resources, trust has to be earned, not every source is reliable, and not every relationship is useful. But too often, we reproduce the same competitive logic we claim to oppose. We talk about solidarity while treating our own websites as little territories. We talk about commons while keeping our work disconnected. We talk about decentralization while building social and technical systems that make cooperation harder than it needs to be.

This is the #geekproblem in a wider social form, the assumption that if we build the right technology, the human relationships will somehow follow. They won’t – a network is made through practice, people have to link, share, maintain, argue, repair and work together. The technology should support those activities rather than pretend to replace them. The OMN is about mediating this mess by making linking part of the infrastructure – the OMN is not another social-media platform competing to own an audience. It is a network of flows, a way to connect independent publishers, community archives, grassroots news projects and other sources through shared data and open protocols.

The basic technical model is straightforward.

  • SUB – flow in. Nodes subscribe to RSS, ActivityPub and other feeds, collecting public information from independent sources.
  • Shared data objects – connect the information. Nodes maintain local copies of text and metadata, preserving links to the original sources and recording provenance.
  • PUB – flow out. Nodes publish selected information through feeds that other projects can reuse, with attribution and links back to the original material.
  • FAT-PING – synchronize the metadata. Participating nodes share tags, classifications and relationships, allowing communities to connect information without requiring one central authority to control the whole network.

This #KISS technical path creates the possibility of something more useful than a collection of disconnected websites.

A local news project could publish reporting that appears in a community feed. An archive could connect that reporting to historical material. Another community could add relevant location or subject tags. Different frontends could present the same information for different purposes.

The original publisher remains visible. The information becomes more useful through connection. The wider network gains value as more people participate, the objective is not to scrape everybody’s content and republish it without permission. It is to build a practical commons around open feeds, clear attribution, appropriate licensing and community control.

The technology should make it easier to send attention outwards, not capture it inwards, we need to move from reciprocal links to reciprocal infrastructure. The original proposal is simple: if linking is going to become central to the #openweb again, the grassroots have to make it happen.

We need to take that idea further – reciprocal linking should be part of a broader practice of reciprocal infrastructure. That means:

  • Linking to relevant work from other independent projects.
  • Citing original sources rather than stripping information of its provenance.
  • Sharing feeds and making independent publishers easier to discover.
  • Connecting community news with historical archives and local knowledge.
  • Maintaining directories and cross-project indexes.
  • Supporting open standards so that information can move between different systems.
  • Building shared infrastructure without requiring every project to surrender its independence.

This is not about #SEO of creating artificial link exchanges or rewarding websites for linking to one another. Nor is it about pretending that every source deserves equal trust. It is about recognizing that the value of an open network comes from useful connections, not isolated ownership. Trust still matters, moderation still matters, communities need to decide what they publish and which sources they rely on. But these decisions should help build better flows rather than turn every community into another closed silo.

The political choice is simple (#KISS) – we have spent years watching the commercial internet turn relationships into engagement metrics, communities into audiences and information into a resource to be enclosed. The #openweb offers another possibility, but only if we are willing to practise it. This is not about abandoning individual projects, it is about making them part of a living commons. A river does not become powerful by keeping every drop in a separate container. It becomes powerful through the connections between its springs, streams and tributaries. The same is true of the #openweb.

Ten years ago, the problem was that nobody was linking to anybody. Today, we have more technical ways to connect, but we still need the social practice that makes those connections matter. The #OMN is one path to build that practice into the infrastructure itself, not another platform, not another silo. A network of flows, built by the people who need to begin to rebuild the #openweb.

I should LINK from this post, please post URLs in the comments.

#OMN #openweb #Fediverse #ActivityPub #RSS #indymedia #commons

The Tragedy of Soviet Market Economists: Civilizing Russia, or whitewashing Neoliberalism?

Dr Tobias Rupprecht’s seminar at St Antony’s College was The Tragedy of Soviet Market Economists: The Failed Quest to Civilise Russia, 1972–2022. But sitting through the discussion, I was left wondering whose tragedy we were really talking about, and who gets to define what it means to civilize a country. The nitpicking Oxford event kinda made sense, but pull back and my impression was that this was an apologetic account of the #neoliberal project in Russia: a story that gives market liberalism respectable historical roots while leaving too many of its own political responsibilities unexplored.

This guy looks so uncomfortable presenting his book, not surprising as his book is about rejuvenation of shock doctrine neoliberalism in Russia. This should feel uncomfortable, as for the last 20 years this same mess has ripped apart the global economy and society. Its a mess we need to compost not something to nitpick thought as liberal apology.

One of the striking things was the attempt to present Chicago School economics as something that grew naturally out of Russian experience. What was missing was any account of the international circulation of neoliberal ideas, the networks promoting them, and the ideological project that had been developing since the late 1940s. #Neoliberalism did not emerge from Russian soil, it had a history, a political purpose and powerful international connections.

The discussion of perestroika seemed equally uncomfortable. Liberalism was presented as having little or no role in the process, which was instead framed as purely Communist. But this leaves the central question hanging: how did market liberalism become such a powerful force in the transformation of the Soviet system?

Then there was the constitutional crisis, the bombing of parliament and the question of political responsibility. The impression he gives was that the liberals had clean hands. Anatoly Chubais was presented sympathetically, despite his central role in the “reforms” and upheavals of the period. The liberals helped bring Putin to power, then found themselves pushing back against the system they had helped create. The Chechen wars and the retreat of democratic liberalism formed part of this story, but the larger political responsibility seemed to dissolve into the narrative.

The Russian liberals were not simply neutral democrats caught in somebody else’s tragedy. They were also participants in a project of internal imperialism: a vision of modernization that treated Russian society as something to be managed, reorganised and disciplined from above. Chubais was described as a democrat while simultaneously expressing deep distrust of the Russian people. That contradiction deserves more judgement than it received in the talk

The comparison with China raised another uncomfortable question. Russia’s industrial development and social security were presented as obstacles to the transformation being attempted, while China’s large peasant population and overseas connections offered different conditions for market reform. But if the argument is that existing social protections made a country harder to reshape for the market, perhaps we should ask what kind of progress this version of liberalism actually represents.

At one point, a question about soviet algorithms prompted laughter in the room. Yet the wider discussion seemed to leave the basic assumptions of neoliberalism untouched. That was the most revealing part of the event for me. The room was bowing before the #deathcult, the belief that the market is the inevitable measure of progress, that societies must be remade in its image, and that the damage caused along the way is a regrettable but necessary price.

Nobody was willing to challenge the underlying framework directly, nobody in the room had any clothes on – the ideological assumptions were exposed – but the performance of respectable scholarship continued. Only one question near the end felt genuinely sane: an older woman asking something that cut through the comfortable narrative.

The tragedy is not that Soviet market economists failed in their quest to “civilise” Russia, it is more that the idea of civilizing a society through market discipline was part of the problem from the beginning. Liberalism presents itself as common sense, modernization and freedom. But when its advocates distrust the people they claim to liberate, excuse the violence of transformation, and treat social protections as barriers to progress, we should ask whose freedom is actually being served.

This is the wider problem with our worship of the #deathcult,turning blinded ideology into an unquestionable reality. Once that happens, the discussion examines every historical detail except the assumptions that hold the whole story together. We need to stop treating neoliberalism as the neutral destination of history. We need to examine the power behind it, the social damage it leaves behind, and the alternatives that have been pushed aside.

That means building from the grassroots, through open processes and shared power, rather than imagining that societies can be perfected by economists, markets and elitists who do not trust the people they govern. The question is not whether Russia was sufficiently civilised for the market, it is whether the market’s self-appointed civilisers were ever willing to recognize the people whose lives they were reshaping.

The event was about teaching the young people that liberalism was not responsible for the mess… and the polite youth lap it up, no critical questions from them in the Q&A

END.

#Oxford #Talk #Event